Same fund, different costs: Understanding mutual fund share classes

Open full sized image

Same investments. Different fee structures.

© Nero Pimentel/stock.adobe.com; Photo illustration Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.

When you search for a mutual fund on a fund company’s website, you may find several versions of the same fund. They may be noted as Class A or Class C shares, or have labels such as “institutional” or “retirement,” with each featuring its own ticker symbol and fee structure.

These seemingly different versions of the same fund are known as mutual fund share classes. Although different share classes of the same fund generally hold the same investments and follow the same strategy, their fees and eligibility requirements can differ. Those differences matter, because higher fees can reduce your investment returns over time.

Fund companies offer different share classes for different types of investors and ways of buying a fund. Some classes include fees to compensate intermediaries that help sell and service the fund, such as brokers, insurance companies, financial advisors, and retirement plan administrators. Other classes are created for particular types of investors or accounts.

Some mutual fund share classes charge a sales commission, or load, that compensates the broker or advisor who sells the fund. Loads are separate from a fund’s ongoing operating expenses and can be charged when you buy or sell shares.

A front-end load is deducted when you purchase shares. So if you put $1,000 into a fund with a 5% front-end load, $50 goes toward the sales charge, leaving $950 to be invested. Class A shares typically use this structure and generally have lower ongoing 12b-1 fees than other share classes that charge sales loads. Some investors may qualify for load-waived Class A shares or breakpoint discounts, which reduce the sales charge when qualifying investments reach certain levels.

Class B shares are no longer widely available, although you may still encounter them in older investments. Unlike Class A shares, they generally have no front-end load but carry higher 12b-1 fees. They may also charge a back-end load, or contingent deferred sales charge, when you sell shares. That charge typically decreases or disappears the longer you hold the fund.

Class C shares typically have no front-end sales load but may charge a back-end load if you sell within a specified period, often a year. They generally carry higher ongoing 12b-1 fees than other share classes that charge sales loads, so their costs can add up the longer you hold them.

Not every mutual fund share class comes with a sales load. Some are aimed at individual investors, while others are created for institutions or workplace retirement plans. They may have different investment minimums, ongoing expenses, and eligibility requirements.

No-load mutual funds don’t charge front- or back-end sales loads, but that doesn’t mean they’re free. They still have ongoing operating costs, such as management fees, and some charge 12b-1 fees. You can typically find no-load shares through a brokerage account, directly from a fund company, or through a financial advisor.

Institutional shares, sometimes labeled Class I or Y, are generally aimed at investors with deep pockets, such as institutions that are able to meet high investment minimums. They often have some of the lowest ongoing expenses. But you don’t necessarily need $1 million lying around to get access: Individual investors may be able to own institutional shares through a 401(k) or other workplace retirement plan or through an investment advisory account.

Retirement shares, often labeled Class R, are created specifically for employer-sponsored retirement plans such as 401(k)s and 403(b)s. Their fees can vary widely; some have low ongoing costs, while others include expenses associated with administering the retirement plan.

The best fit often depends on how much you invest, how long you plan to hold the fund, and which classes are available to you.

What about a 401(k)? If you invest through an employer-sponsored retirement plan, you may not have a choice of share class. Your plan determines what’s available, which may include institutional shares or retirement shares such as Class R.

If you buy mutual funds through your own brokerage account or directly from a fund company, you may have a choice among share classes. Dig into the fund’s website and prospectus to compare sales loads, expense ratios, and other ongoing costs. Tools such as the FINRA Fund Analyzer and Morningstar can also help you research and compare costs. If you invest through an employer-sponsored retirement plan, you generally won’t choose the share class; your plan determines what’s available. Still, understanding share classes can help you know what you’re paying and why.