Types of novel

Real, as opposed to imaginary, human life provides so much ready-made material for the novelist that it is not surprising to find in many novels a mere thinly disguised and minimally reorganized representation of actuality. When, for the fullest appreciation of a work of fiction, it is necessary for the reader to consult the real-life personages and events that inspired it, then the work is a roman à clef, a novel that needs a key. In a general sense, every work of literary art requires a key or clue to the artist’s preoccupations (the jail in Dickens; the mysterious tyrants in Kafka, both leading back to the author’s own father), but the true roman à clef is more particular in its disguised references. George Orwell’s Animal Farm (1945), for example, makes total sense only when its hidden historical content is disclosed. D.H. Lawrence’s Aaron’s Rod requires a knowledge of the author’s personal enmities, and to understand Aldous Huxley’s Point Counter Point fully one must know, for instance, that the character of Mark Rampion is Lawrence himself and that of Denis Burlap is the critic John Middleton Murry. Proust’s À la recherche du temps perdu becomes a richer literary experience when the author’s social milieu is explored, and Joyce’s Finnegans Wake has so many personal references that it may be called the most massive roman à clef ever written. The more important the clef becomes to full understanding, the closer the work has come to a special kind of didacticism. When it is dangerous to expose the truth directly, then the novel may present it obliquely. But the ultimate vitality of the work will depend on those elements in it that require no key.

Antinovel

The movement away from the traditional novel form in France in the form of the nouveau roman (New Novel) tends to an ideal that may be called the antinovel—a work of the fictional imagination that ignores such properties as plot, dialogue, or human interest. It is impossible, however, for a human creator to create a work of art that is completely inhuman. Twentieth-century French writers such as Alain Robbe-Grillet in Jealousy (1957), Nathalie Sarraute in Tropisms (1939) and The Planetarium (1959), and Michel Butor in Passing Time (1957) and Degrees (1960) wished mainly to remove the pathetic fallacy from fiction, in which the universe, which is indifferent to humans, is made to throw back radar reflections of humans’ own emotions. Individual character is not important, and consciousness dissolves into sheer “perception.” Even time is reversible, since perceptions have nothing to do with chronology, and, as Butor’s Passing Time shows, memories can be lived backward in this sort of novel. Ultimately, the very appearance of the novel—traditionally a model of the temporal treadmill—must change. It will not be obligatory to start at page one and work through to the end: A novel can be entered at any point, like an encyclopedia.

The two terms most heard in connection with the French antinovel are chosisme and tropisme. The first, with which Robbe-Grillet is chiefly associated, relates to the novelist’s concern with things in themselves, not things as human symbols or metaphors. The second, which provided a title for Sarraute’s early novel, denotes the response of the human mind to external stimuli—a response that is general and unmodified by the apparatus of “character.” It is things, the furniture of the universe, that are particular and variable; the multiplicity of human observers melts into an undifferentiable mode of response. Needless to say, there is nothing new in this epistemology as applied to the novel. It is present in Laurence Sterne (in whom French novelists have always been interested) and in Virginia Woolf.

Such British practitioners of the antinovel as Christine Brooke-Rose and Rayner Heppenstall (both French scholars, incidentally) were more empirical than their French counterparts. They objected mainly to the falsification of the external world that was imposed on the traditional novel by the exigencies of plot and character, and they insisted on notating the minutiae of the surface of life, concentrating in an unhurried fashion on every detail of its texture. A work such as Heppenstall’s The Connecting Door (1962), in which the narrator-hero does not even possess a name, is totally unconcerned with action but very interested in buildings, streets, and the sound of music. This is properly a fresh approach to the materials of the traditional novel rather than a total liberation from it. Such innovations as are found in the nouveau roman can best show their value in their influence on traditional novelists, who may be persuaded to observe more closely and be wary of the seductions of swift action, contrived relationships, and neat resolutions.

Cult novels

The novel, unlike the poem, is a commercial commodity, and it lends itself less than the materials of literary magazines to that specialized appeal called coterie, intellectual or elitist. It sometimes happens that books directed at highly cultivated audiences—such as Joyce’s Ulysses and Finnegans Wake and Djuna Barnes’s Nightwood (1936)—achieve a wider response, sometimes because of their daring in the exploitation of sex or obscenity, more often because of a vitality shared with more demotic fiction. The duplicated typescript or the subsidized periodical, rather than the commercially produced book, is the communication medium for the truly hermetic novel.

The novel that achieves commercial publication but whose limited appeal precludes large financial success can frequently become the object of cult adulation or “fandom.” After World War II, especially in the United States, such literary cults were usually composed of students (who, in an era of mass education, formed a sizable percentage of the U.S. population), or youth subcultures, and the novels chosen for cult devotion related to the social or philosophical needs of the readers. The fairy stories of J.R.R. Tolkien, Golding’s Lord of the Flies, and the science fiction of Kurt Vonnegut satisfied, for a greater or lesser time, a hunger for myth, symbols, and heterodox ideas, only to be replaced with surprising speed by other books. The adulation of George Orwell among the young was followed by a bitter reaction against Orwell’s own alleged reactionary tendencies, and such a violent cycle of adoration and detestation is typical of literary cults. Adult cultists tended, like young ones, to be centered in universities, from which they circulated newsletters on Finnegans Wake, Anthony Powell’s A Dance to the Music of Time sequence, and the works of Evelyn Waugh. Occasionally new public attention becomes focused on a neglected author. This happened when the novellas of Ronald Firbank, the anonymous comic novel Augustus Carp, Esq., and G.V. Desani’s All About Mr. Hatterr got back into print because of the urging of devotees. Later novelists whose work attracted dedicated fanbases, especially as fan subcultures migrated to online spaces, include Stephen King, J.K. Rowling, George R.R. Martin, and Donna Tartt.

Detective, mystery, thriller

The terms detective story, mystery, and thriller tend to be employed interchangeably. The detective story thrills the reader with mysterious crimes, usually of a violent nature, and puzzles the reader’s reason until their motivation and their perpetrator are, through some triumph of logic, uncovered. The detective story and mystery are in fact synonymous, but the thriller frequently purveys adventurous frissons without mysteries, like the spy stories of Ian Fleming, for example, but not like the spy stories of Len Deighton, which have a bracing element of mystery and detection. The detective novel began as a respectable branch of literature with such works as Poe’s “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” (1841), Dickens’s unfinished The Mystery of Edwin Drood (1870), and Wilkie Collins’s The Moonstone (1868) and The Woman in White (1860).

With the coming of the Sherlock Holmes stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle at the beginning of the 20th century, the form became a kind of infraliterary subspecies, despite the intellectual brilliance of Holmes’s detective work and the high literacy of Doyle’s writing. Literary men such as G.K. Chesterton practiced the form on the margin, and dons read thrillers furtively or composed them pseudonymously (e.g., J.I.M. Stewart, a student of English literature at Oxford, wrote as “Michael Innes”). Even the British poet laureate C. Day Lewis subsidized his verse through writing detective novels as “Nicholas Blake.” Dorothy L. Sayers, another Oxford scholar, appeared to atone for a highly successful career as a mystery writer by turning to religious drama and the translating of Dante, as well as by making her last mystery novel—Gaudy Night (1935)—a highly literary, even pedantic, confection.

Such practitioners as Agatha Christie, Ellery Queen, Erle Stanley Gardner, Raymond Chandler, to say nothing of the highly commercial Edgar Wallace and Mickey Spillane, have given readers much pleasure and offended only the most exalted literary canons. Many of them came to be regarded as masters of their genres. The fearless and intelligent amateur detective—or private investigator or police officer—became a typical hero of the modern age. And those qualities that good mystery or thriller writing calls for are not to be despised, since they include economy, skillful sustaining of suspense, and very artful plotting.

In the 1950s the mystery novel was superseded in popularity by the novel of espionage, which achieved a large vogue with Fleming’s James Bond series. Something of its spirit, if not its sadism and eroticism, had already appeared in such books as John Buchan’s The Thirty-nine Steps and the “entertainments” of Graham Greene, as well as in the admirable novels of intrigue written by Eric Ambler. Fleming had numerous imitators, as well as a more than worthy successor in Deighton. The novels of John Le Carré found a wide audience despite their emphasis on the less glamorous, often even squalid aspects of international espionage; his works include The Spy Who Came in from the Cold (1963) and Smiley’s People (1980).

By the early 21st century, mysteries and crime thrillers had come roaring back, as evidenced by such bestsellers as Stieg Larsson’s The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2005) and Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl (2012).

Western

Man’s concern with taming wild land, or advancing frontiers, or finding therapy in reversion from the civilized life to the atavistic is well reflected in adventure novels, beginning with James Fenimore Cooper’s novels of the American frontier The Pioneers (1823) and The Last of the Mohicans (1826). As the 19th century advanced, and new tracts of America were opened up, a large body of fiction came out of the men who were involved in pioneering adventure. Mark Twain’s Roughing It (1872) may be called a frontier classic. Bret Harte wrote shorter fiction, such as “The Luck of Roaring Camp” (1868), but helped to spread an interest in frontier writing to Europe, where the cult of what may be termed the western novel is as powerful as in America. Owen Wister’s The Virginian (1902), Andy Adams’s near-documentary The Log of a Cowboy (1903), Emerson Hough’s The Covered Wagon (1922), from which the first important western film was made in 1923, Hamlin Garland’s A Son of the Middle Border (1917), and O.E. Rölvaag’s Giants in the Earth (1927) all helped to make the form popular, but it is to Zane Grey—who wrote more than 50 western novels—that lovers of frontier myth have accorded the greatest devotion. The western is now thought of predominantly as a cinematic form, but it arose out of literature.

Other frontier fiction has come from another “New World,” the antipodes—South Africa as well as the Australian Outback—but the American West has arguably provided the best mythology, and it is still capable of literary treatment, as the well-regarded novels by Charles Portis, Larry McMurtry, Cormac McCarthy, and Annie Proulx confirm. Sophisticated literary devices may be grafted onto the western—surrealistic fantasy or parallels to Shakespeare or to the ancient classics—but the peculiar and perennial appeal of the western lies in its ethical simplicity, the frequent violence, and the desperate attempt to maintain minimal civilized order, as well as the stark, near-epic figures from true western history, such as Billy the Kid, Calamity Jane, Wyatt Earp, Annie Oakley, and Jesse James.

Beginning in the latter half of the 20th century, Native American authors offered a counterpoint to the classic western novel. Such writers as N. Scott Momaday, Leslie Marmon Silko, Louise Erdrich, Sherman Alexie, and Tommy Orange explored the impact of European colonization on Indigenous communities and identities, the modern realities of reservation life, and the experiences of urban Native Americans, who are all but absent in the white western novel.