transnationalism
-
What is transnationalism?
Transnationalism refers to economic, political, and cultural processes that extend beyond the boundaries of nation-states. It suggests a weakening of a nation-state's control over its borders, inhabitants, and territory.
Processes contributing to transnationalism include the economic influences of corporations operating globally, cooperative agreements between governments, and growing economic dependence among developed nations on migrant group labor. Increased immigration, combined with advances in technology, allows immigrants to maintain contact with their culture of origin, resulting in multicultural societies. Transnationalism is commonly contrasted with nationalism, where national interests are seen as paramount.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
How is transnationalism different from international relations?
Transnationalism differs from international relations by emphasizing processes extending beyond nation-state boundaries, such as economic, political, and cultural exchanges. It suggests a weakening of national control due to increased global mobility, communication, and multiculturalism.
International relations, on the other hand, studies the interactions between states, international organizations, and subnational entities. While international relations focus on state-level interactions, transnationalism highlights how globalization connects people and organizations across borders, potentially challenging state authority. Transnational activities are anchored in and transcend one or more nation-states.
5 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
What are some examples of transnational activities or connections?
Transnationalism encompasses economic, political, and cultural processes extending beyond nation-state boundaries. Examples include corporations operating globally and cooperative agreements between governments, fostering trade and job opportunities. Advances in transportation and communication, like the Internet, enhance connectivity for individuals moving across borders.
Increased immigration creates multicultural societies where immigrants maintain ties to their origin cultures, leading to complex allegiances. Transnational social movements, such as the antiglobalization movement, also exemplify transnational activities. These movements address issues spanning multiple countries, often challenging governments and international institutions.
5 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
How does migration contribute to transnationalism?
Migration significantly contributes to transnationalism by creating interconnectedness that stretches beyond nation-state boundaries. As people migrate, they often maintain ties to their home countries while integrating into new societies, forming a relationship of interdependence between their country of origin and their country of residence.
These connections are strengthened by advances in transportation and communication technologies, such as the Internet, which allow migrants to maintain virtual connectivity. This leads to dual loyalties, where individuals feel a sense of belonging to both their home and host countries, mixing both in their daily lives. This interconnectedness dissolves traditional boundaries and reduces the relevance of territorial controls imposed by nation-states.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
How do transnational communities maintain ties with their home countries?
Transnational communities maintain ties with their home countries through various channels. These connections are reinforced through immigration laws, political and religious groups, and family connections. Economic interdependence between nations and their transnational communities, driven by globalization, prompts governments to redefine citizenship and nationality.
Advances in transportation and communication, like the Internet, enable virtual connectivity, while host countries' shift towards multicultural approaches also plays a crucial role. Individuals now often combine identities, feeling connected to both their home and host countries.
2 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
What impact does transnationalism have on culture and identity?
Transnationalism, where economic, political, and cultural processes extend beyond national boundaries, impacts culture and identity by potentially weakening the control a nation-state has over its inhabitants. Increased immigration leads to multicultural societies where immigrants maintain ties to their culture of origin, resulting in competing loyalties between the state and their culture or religion.
With increased global mobility and communication, national boundaries become less relevant, though state definitions of citizenship may become more important for transnational groups. Some argue that a global culture is forming among individuals with similar values, while others believe local cultures persist. This creates a tension between national identity and transnational ties.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.
transnationalism, economic, political, and cultural processes that extend beyond the boundaries of nation-states.
The concept of transnationalism suggests a weakening of the control a nation-state has over its borders, inhabitants, and territory. Increased immigration to developed countries in response to global economic development has resulted in multicultural societies where immigrants are more likely to maintain contact with their culture of origin and less likely to assimilate. Therefore, loyalty to the state may compete equally with allegiance to a culture or religion. With increased global mobility and access to instantaneous worldwide communication technology, boundaries dissolve and the territorial controls imposed by the traditional nation-state become less relevant. However, state definitions of citizenship and nationality and the rules for political participation may become more relevant for transnational groups.
Globalization is a related concept that represents the intensification of economic, cultural, and political practices accelerating across the globe in the early 21st century. Although many large corporations have been operating globally for decades, the Internet has enabled small organizations and individuals to access instantaneously a worldwide communication network. Global processes are closely related to transnationalism yet tend to be separate from specific national boundaries. Transnational processes, on the other hand, are anchored in and transcend one or more nation-states. The impacts of the transnational migration of groups, although different, need to be understood within the context of globalization. The changes created by each are mutually reinforcing.
" height="20" alt="HEW Logo">
Processes of transnationalism
Processes contributing to transnationalism include the economic influences of corporations operating globally, often referred to as transnational corporations, and cooperative agreements between governments. These arrangements offer new trade and industrial opportunities for private business and government alike. New prospects for employment in developed nations tend to draw migrant groups from less-developed nations. New advances in transportation and communication technologies, such as the Internet, provide potential avenues of virtual connectivity among these individuals and groups moving across national borders. The formation of the European Union resulted in the reexamination of long-term relationships with transnational groups (such as the Turkish and Kurdish populations).
Another major process influencing transnationalism is the growing economic dependence among developed nations on migrant group labour. The relationship between these groups and their nations of residence has become one of interdependence. Beyond economic considerations, this implies that host countries reciprocate by providing avenues for civic participation and in some cases the rights of citizenship for transnational groups.
Transnationalism and nationalism
Transnationalism is commonly contrasted with nationalism. Here, nationalism is characterized as a strong belief among people who share a common language, history, and culture that the interests of the nation-state are paramount. This requires a strong sense of belonging, identity, and loyalty where the benefits of membership are acquired through citizenship. Historically, migrant groups moving from one nation to another were expected to prove their belonging and loyalty by adopting the prescribed moral and political values of their nation of immigration. Permanent residence carried an expectation of acquired citizenship and nationality in those countries based on notions of “national assimilation” (e.g., United States and France) as opposed to ancestry (such as Germany). After a generation, many of these groups were fully assimilated into the dominant culture of the nation of immigration. For many, the connection with their country of emigration took the form of diaspora—the formation of tightly bounded communities on the basis of common cultural and ethnic references between places of origin and arrival. This dynamic gave rise to large numbers of ethnic communities within nation-states, retaining elements of culture in terms of identity yet remaining subservient to national loyalty. Nonetheless, the loyalties of migrant groups often transcend this critical feature of the nation-state with primary allegiance and identity given to religion or their culture of origin. Dual loyalties have led some nations to liberalize their laws regarding dual citizenship or provide rights and privileges to noncitizen groups who permanently reside within their borders, while others have adopted the opposite position and made their immigration policies more exclusionary.
Transnational communities and pressure for change
Transnational community refers to those groups who migrate and reside in a receiving nation for a considerable time yet maintain strong transnational ties. Those ties may be reinforced formally by the rules and regulations of the state (immigration laws, definitions of citizenship), by links with political parties or religious groups, or informally through connections among families and households in the sending and receiving countries. As developed nations became more economically dependent on immigrant workers, there was more political pressure for the state to enter reciprocal relationships with those groups, particularly those of long-term residence. For example, until 2000 the rules and regulations for defining and obtaining German citizenship excluded the substantial long-residing Turkish population in the country. Many Turkish citizens had lived in Germany for many decades and desired dual citizenship. They defined citizenship in terms of political representation and nationality as an ethnic identity conflicting with the German definition of citizenship, which combined citizenship with nationality. The Turkish minority was rooted in a Turkish national identity and a Muslim religious identity, both foreign to the German collective identity, yet Germany was in many ways economically dependent on that minority. Pressure for change resulted in the reform of Germany’s citizenship and nationality law in 2000. While still not allowing for dual citizenship, the regulations governing naturalization of foreign nationals were liberalized, and it became possible to acquire German citizenship as a result of being born in Germany.
The trusted destination for professionals, college students, and lifelong learners.
SUBSCRIBE
The economic interdependence between nation-states and their transnational communities, engendered by forces of globalization, are forcing state action to redefine concepts such as citizenship and nationality, which are deeply embedded in a nation’s culture, history, and traditions.