What Is the Importance of the Battle of Blair Mountain?
What was the Battle of Blair Mountain?
Why did the miners march at Blair Mountain?
What were the immediate impacts of the Battle of Blair Mountain?
Could the Battle of Blair Mountain have been avoided?
What is the legacy of the Battle of Blair Mountain today?
More than 10,000 Americans marched against a force armed with machine guns and aerial bombs. Combatants buried their dead in the depths of the mountains. They were not fighting a foreign adversary, nor was this an episode from the American Civil War.
This was the Battle of Blair Mountain in West Virginia, 1921. Its history features coal miners, mining companies, and various tiers of the American government. Poor Americans across ethnic linesâincluding Black workers from the Deep South, women, and immigrantsâwere united by a claim to dignity and health. Even as they fired their rifles, they held faith in the federal government to recognize their fight for rights.
The conflict between union miners and mining companies followed decades of conflict between labor and management. Although some consider the death toll (an estimated 20â50 people) relatively modest, the subsequent decade was the deadliest for miners. Despite hopes from both sides that the battle would finally put an end to the long-standing dispute over workersâ rightsâone way or anotherâno meaningful policy reform immediately followed. The labor battle continued through the 20th century and shapes the socioeconomic makeup of West Virginia today.
The story of Blair Mountain is a hard one to tell because it neither began nor ended with the battle in 1921. Its legacy continues to be disputed, and its roots can be traced back to the labor wars of the 19th century.
The labor wars (1870sâ1930s)
The booms and busts of miner resistance in the United States stretch back to the 1870s. From the 20 Pennsylvania miners hanged after an 1874 strike to the 50 people killed in conflicts between unionized miners and mine operators while martial law was in place in West Virginia in 1912, the history of violence between miners, mining companies, and the state predates the Battle of Blair Mountain. After the Russian Revolution in 1917, labor unrest in the United Statesâincluding peaceful strikesâbecame increasingly associated with fears of communism in the First Red Scare, a period of widespread fear of communism and radical labor movements in the United States. Ultimately, these clashes did not secure workersâ intended rights, except for minor pay increases in 1902 and 1912. The labor wars laid the groundwork for the mine wars in West Virginia (1912â21), and specifically the Battle of Blair Mountain.
The Battle of Blair Mountain
Miners evicted in Mingo county
In May 1920 thousands of coal miners from Mingo county, West Virginia, were signing up to join the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA). Although the UMWA had successfully secured wage increases for its union miners across the state, coal companies had denied similar benefits to the non-union miners in Mingo. One mining company, the Howard Colliery at Chattaroy, offered an increase in wages but simultaneously increased prices at the company store, the sole location where miners could buy daily necessities (coal miners were paid in company scrip, which was exchangeable only at the company store). These conditions fostered successful organizing efforts by the UMWA in Mingo.
Coal companies responded by firing union miners and evicting them from company-owned homes. Because minersâ tenancy depended on their employment, losing a job often meant losing a home as well. These evictions were usually enforced by agents of the Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency, a private force employed by coal companies.
The trusted destination for professionals, college students, and lifelong learners.
SUBSCRIBE
A shoot-out at Matewan
On the morning of May 19, 1920, Baldwin-Felts agents came to the town of Matewan in Mingo county to enforce the coal companiesâ eviction orders. The agencyâs field superintendent, Albert Felts, sought out Matewan mayor Cabell Testerman to obtain permission to install machine guns on the roofs of buildings for his agentsâ use, claiming it was a necessary precaution to keep the peace. Despite a bribe that accompanied the request, Testerman refused. Testerman was an ally to the union, along with the Matewan police chief, Sid Hatfield.
Later that afternoon, Felts and his agents began evicting miners from their company-owned homes. Testerman and Hatfield approached the agents to arrest them for carrying out what they believed were illegal eviction orders. They were accompanied by armed miners whom Testerman had deputized for support. Felts responded by stating that he had a warrant for Hatfieldâs arrest. When Testerman reviewed the warrant, he declared it a fake.
A shoot-out erupted; sources disagree on who fired the first shot. By the end of the confrontation, 10 were dead: Testerman, 7 Baldwin-Felts agents, including Albert Felts, and 2 miners. Hatfield went to trial for his involvement in the shoot-out and was acquitted in March 1921 by a jury. The incident elevated his reputation as a champion of the miners and a symbol of resistance to the coal companies and their hired enforcers.
Tensions rise in Mingo county
Disputes escalated between miners and coal companies over the following year. One major altercation was the Three Daysâ Battle, or the Battle of the Tug, during which thousands of gunshots were exchanged between striking miners and strikebreakers supported by law enforcement. On May 19, 1921, West Virginia Gov. Ephraim Morgan declared martial law, stating that West Virginia was in a âstate of war, insurrection and riot.â
A militia led by Adj. Gen. Thomas B. Davis arrested miners in Mingo county for carrying union literature, criticizing martial law, and carrying arms. The arrests were carried out without warrants or hearings. As national attention to the events in West Virginia rose, labor leaders lobbied for an inquiry by the U.S. Senate into the treatment of miners. Eventually Sen. Hiram Johnson of California filed a resolution to investigate the violence in West Virginia. In late June, his resolution was adopted by the Senate.
âThere never has been in our history, if these stories be accurate, anything like the conditions that obtain today in this territory at our very doors.ââU.S. Sen. Hiram Johnson
In July, a Senate committee led by Sen. William Kenyon of Iowa sought testimony from labor leaders, union miners, and representatives of coal companies. These hearings, however, did not directly lead to legislative change or provide a resolution to the escalating violence.
Catalytic killings
On August 1, Sid Hatfield and his friend Ed Chambers were shot on the steps of the McDowell county courthouse by Baldwin-Felts agents in Welch, West Virginia. Hatfield was hit four times, and Chambers was shot in the neck and behind his right ear. Their spouses were present at the scene. Jessie Hatfield ran to seek help from the police, while Sallie Chambers struck one of the agents with her umbrella and had to be dragged away. The agents planted pistols on the bodies to later claim that they had fired on Hatfield and Chambers in self-defense. Although the agents were brought to trial, they were acquitted by a jury.
âDeliberately shot down, murdered in cold bloodâŠand by whom? Men who are working under the direction of and taking their orders from coal operatorsâŠSleek, dignified churchgoing gentlemen, who would rather pay fabulous sums to their hired gunmen, to kill and slay men for joining a union than to pay like or less amounts to the men who delve into the subterranean depths of the earth and produce their wealth for them.ââformer counsel for the UMWA Sam Montgomery, at Hatfield and Chambersâs funeral
An estimated 2,000 union miners attended Hatfield and Chambersâs funeral procession. It had been five months since Hatfield had been acquitted of his involvement at Matewan, when he had intervened in the agentsâ work to evict the miners.
In the wake of the killings, UMWA leaders Fred Mooney and Frank Keeney called off plans to send large numbers of organizers into Mingo county to be arrested and overwhelm the county jails out of fear that their men might be killed as well. Labor activist Mother Jones called on the two leaders to organize a mass meeting. When Mooney and Keeney resisted, for fear that a gathering would lead to more arrests of miners, she organized a protest meeting of about 25 miners herself. Under pressure, Mooney and Keeney held a meeting on August 7 with about 500 miners across the street from Governor Morganâs home.
Following the meeting, UMWA leaders Mooney and Keeney presented a list of demands to Morgan. These demands included an eight-hour workday and a joint commission of managers and workers to mediate disputes. Ten days later, Morgan rejected all their demands. He did not consider the UMWA a legitimate representative of the miners.
âI have no home, except where there is struggle.ââMother Jones
Mary Harris Jones was a social revolutionary Irishwoman who migrated to America during the Great Famine (1845â49), lost her husband and four children to a yellow fever epidemic, and saw her dressmaking business burn during the 1871 Chicago Fire. When she walked into a minersâ camp in 1901, recruiting for the UMWA, she sparked a labor fight that would escalate over decades to come.
Miners gather at Marmet
News of Morganâs rejection of the UMWAâs demands fomented calls to march on Mingo county. By August 20, about 600 miners had gathered near the town of Marmet, just southeast of Charleston, West Virginia. In a matter of days, this number had swelled to about 10,000. Their intention was to free jailed union organizers and miners in Mingo county, about 70 miles (110 km) away. But getting there would first mean crossing Blair Mountain in neighboring Logan county, whose sheriff, Don Chafin, had vowed to block any union advance into his county. For years, Chafin and his deputies had been paid by coal mine operators to suppress union activity, using intimidation, beatings, arrests, and evictions to keep the UMWA out of the county.
In anticipation of the minersâ march, Morgan wrote to U.S. Pres. Warren G. Harding, requesting federal troops and military aircraft armed with machine guns. Hardingâs administration had previously rebuffed Morganâs requests for military support but decided to send Brig. Gen. Harry Bandholtz to West Virginia to assess the situation. When Bandholtz arrived, he asked Morgan if he had done all he could to resolve the problem, to which Morgan stated that he had.
âThere is no fight in West Virginia between the operator and the union miners.ââGov. Ephraim Morgan
A truce formed and broken
In the early morning of August 27, Bandholtz called Mooney and Keeney for a meeting, appealing to them to persuade the miners to stand down. He gave them a memo with his signature, which would prove to the miners that the federal government wanted them to stand down.
âI am going to give you a chance to save them, and if you cannot turn them back we are going to snuff this out just like that.ââBrig. Gen. Harry Bandholtz
Mooney and Keeney immediately went to Marmet to share Bandholtzâs message with the miners. The miners agreed to comply, though tensions remained high. When Bandholtz drove to Marmet himself later in the day, he observed miners turning back from the direction of Mingo county. He informed the War Department that federal troops were no longer necessary.
But news had not yet spread of a shoot-out involving Chafinâs officers in Sharples, a town about 40 miles south of Marmet, that had taken place that afternoon. Reports of the incident reached Marmet the next day, August 28. Over the next few days, anger directed at Chafin spurred the miners to resume their march. Mooney and Keeney fled the state, leaving leadership of the miners in the hands of UMWA leader Bill Blizzard.
The battle in the mountains
As the miners gathered to take Blair Mountain from the north, Logan county forces gathered by Chafin were waiting. They had fortified their position on the mountain, armed with ammunition, rifles, machine guns, and even airplanes.
The final attempt to stop further bloodshed without the use of federal troops came in the form of a proclamation from President Harding. On August 30, he called for both the marching miners and the Logan county forces to disperse by noon on September 1. Private airplanes dropped copies of Hardingâs proclamation, but neither side complied. By September 1 the total number of combatants numbered between 10,000 and 20,000.
As the miners began to scale the mountain in scattered individual units, Logan county forces applied heavy defensive fire. On September 1, Chafin deployed rented commercial aircraft to drop pipe bombs and tear gas on locations where the miners were suspected to be regrouping for further assaults.
â[Machine gun fire] would echo and roll around so much sometimes you would think they was right down in Blair. Machine guns cracked up there so you would think the whole place was coming down on you.ââminer Ira Wilson
The arrival of federal troops put an end to the conflict. About 2,100 federal soldiers arrived on September 2, and Bandholtz declared a ceasefire the next day. Logan county forces received word from Governor Morgan to comply with Bandholtzâs directives, and the miners surrendered, unwilling to oppose the national government, which many of them had fought for years before in World War I.
What were the immediate impacts?
Despite the minersâ hopes that federal intervention at Blair Mountain might mean the beginning of a renewed national focus on their working conditions in West Virginia, no lasting response was seen from Congress.
Death toll estimates range from 20 to more than 50. Given there were 10,000â20,000 combatants, it is possible this number was far greater, but the exact death toll is unknown. Some say that this is partly because both miners and coal companies deliberately hid these figures, secretly burying their dead in the mountains, so as not to show weakness to the enemy. Mining continued to be deadly for workers for the following decade. The 1920s were the deadliest time in West Virginia history to be a coal miner, with poor working conditions contributing to an average of 400 deaths per year.
After the Battle of Blair Mountain, membership in the West Virginia UMWA plummeted from more than 50,000 to a few hundred by 1929. National membership also dropped from more than 600,000 to fewer than 100,000. UMWA national leader John L. Lewis forced local leaders Frank Keeney and Fred Mooney to resign in June 1924. The UMWA presence in West Virginia was left leaderless and weathered.
âNo backward step was taken but the ground lost by the union became a landslide into the gutter for the union.ââFred Mooney
That being said, Bill Blizzard, leader of the miners at Blair Mountain, was acquitted of treason against West Virginia in 1922. This was a drastic change from the days of the militant American abolitionist John Brown, who was sentenced to death in 1859 for his violent resistance. Still, these legal battles and the year of strikes drained the UMWA financially. This was exacerbated by the 1929 Great Depression, the slashing of worker wages, and the coal companiesâ monopoly of the company townâas described by Carl Sandburg, who often wrote on class divide, in his poem âCompany Townâ: âYou all drink company water / And all use company lights, / The company preacher teaches us / What the company thinks is right.â
The economic repercussions of Blair Mountain and the gradual decline of the coal industry are felt to this day. West Virginia is one of the poorest states in the U.S. More than 45 percent of households struggle to afford basic needs, including housing and health care. The median household income is $20,000 below the national median, and thousands of jobs have been cut as mining operations close. Mingo, McDowell, and Loganâcounties sustained by coal and home to miner resistanceâare among the five West Virginia counties with the highest poverty rates.
Was there progress after the Battle of Blair Mountain?
Although milestones of progress in the minersâ struggle are difficult to attribute exclusively to the Battle of Blair Mountain, workers achieved some victories in its wake.
Before the Battle of Blair Mountain, miners in the U.S. were associated with the Red Scare. When the miners laid down their arms at the arrival of federal troops at Blair Mountain, it became clear that their loyalty belonged to the United States, and that their goal was not to mount a Communism-inspired insurrection. The narrative shifted accordingly. Union organizer Frank Keeney explained, âYou can fight the government of West Virginia, but by God, you canât fight the government of the United States.â
On March 23, 1932, the miners saw another step forward in guaranteeing their rights. Pres. Herbert Hoover signed the NorrisâLa Guardia Act into law, outlawing âyellow-dog contractsâ that had required miners to abstain from union participation to be employed. The act also enabled miners to form labor unions without federal interference.
In 1933 newly elected Pres. Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA), granting workers the right to organize, resulting in the rapid resurgence of the UMWA.
Why is this a hard story to tell?
âThe Battle of Blair Mountain did not end. It simply changed locations. As long as humans can get rich from digging things out of the ground, they will continue to do so. Wherever they do, there will be conflict, and someone will later try to cover it up.ââhistorian Charles Keeney, great-grandson of Frank Keeney
The legacy of the battle continued to be contested long after 1921. Not only did the miners take a vow of silence not to discuss union business in public, and so were unable to document their side of history, but the media and education systems actively excluded the miner perspective from the history of Blair Mountain. The mine wars were omitted from West Virginia school textbooks, replaced with a patriotic version of the coal industryâs history. Today, when advocates of the oppressed workers from 100 years ago raise concerns about the historic deprivation of miners, some locals perceive it as a threat to their current livelihoods. Several books about the coal wars have gone on to be published, and journalist Robert Shoganâs The Battle of Blair Mountain (2004) is considered a major secondary source on the events that precipitated the conflict.
Although there is no official monument to honor the battle, Blair Mountain was considered for the National Register of Historic Places in 2008. The designation was delayed by major coal operators who were interested in the approximately $200 million worth of coal in the mountain. It was added to the register in 2018.
The story of Blair Mountain is a hard one to tell, because it is still being written.
The struggle of miners today
Many modern West Virginians live a continuation of the 1921 conflict. Over 100 years later, the primary fronts of the miner struggle remain the same: workplace safety, health monitoring, and state tensions.
Despite the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, the central Appalachian region has experienced a massive resurgence of a form of black lung disease (coal-workersâ pneumoconiosis). Miners were entitled to new medical screenings and monitoring by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). In April 2025, Pres. Donald Trumpâs administration announced staffing reductions affecting 90 percent of the NIOSH workforce. Following pressure from labor unions, miners, public health experts, and members of Congress, many of those positions were subsequently restored in early 2026. Modern infrastructure protecting minersâ health and workplace safety is still reliant on active protest and resistance.
The spirit of the battle lives on with locals, union activists, and even environmentalists, such as those who marked the battleâs 90th anniversary by retracing the 50-mile march from Marmet to Blair Mountain in June 2011. West Virginia Sen. Jim Justice, whose family owns coal companies, recognized the significance of the Battle of Blair Mountain as a âfight for fair treatment of working peoples.â
Today, the Blair Mountain battlefield has transformed into a platform for progress, where the enduring fight for workersâ health, rights, and dignity is no longer buried in the mountains but solidifying into the American conscience.
