- Born:
- May 11, 1912, Samrala, Ludhiana district, Punjab province, British India
Saadat Hasan Manto
Who was Saadat Hasan Manto?
What were some themes in Saadat Hasan Mantoâs works?
What influenced Saadat Hasan Mantoâs literary style?
What are some of Saadat Hasan Mantoâs notable short stories?
What challenges did Saadat Hasan Manto face in his life?
Saadat Hasan Manto (born May 11, 1912, Samrala, Ludhiana district, Punjab province, British Indiaâdied January 18, 1955, Lahore, Pakistan) was an Indo-Pakistani writer of Urdu fiction and nonfiction whose works presented untempered depictions of the grim realities of society, including sexual violence, prostitution, murder, the inhumanity and trauma brought on by the partition of India, and more. His oeuvre of more than 250 short stories, written in incisive prose, unsettled readers and resulted in multiple court trials for obscenity. However, the writer forged on and even proclaimed, âIf you cannot bear these stories then the society is unbearable.â
Initial years
Manto, the son of Ghulam Hasan and his second wife, Sardar Begum, was born in a Kashmiri Muslim family. Hasan, who was a judge, had high academic expectations for his son. Manto went to school in Amritsar, Punjab province, and Hasan expected him to perform well and become a lawyer. Manto, however, did not show academic promise, failing his matriculation exam twiceâeven in Urdu as a subject.
Mantoâs relationship with his father remained strained, and it is said that Hasanâs stern demeanor fueled the rebel in his son. In contrast, Mantoâs mother showered him with affection. Their differing influences may be discerned in Mantoâs portrayals of a number of negative male characters juxtaposed with sensitive women and tender maternal figures, notably Zubaida in âAulaadâ (âOffspringâ) and Nikki and Sharda in eponymous stories.
In 1934 Manto enrolled at Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), struggling again as a student. He dropped out within months after being diagnosed with tuberculosis, although it turned out to be a false alarm. However, he had already begun writing, having translated French author Victor Hugoâs The Last Days of a Condemned and Irish writer Oscar Wildeâs Vera. During his months at AMU, Manto also wrote and published original stories. Later he worked at various organizations, including Paras magazine in Lahore (now in Pakistan), a film weekly called Musawwar in Bombay (now Mumbai), and All India Radio in Delhi. He eventually settled in Bombay, a city dear to him.
Works
Manto lived through tumultuous times. During his formative years, India was going through political unrest, struggling to gain freedom from colonial rule. Indiaâs independence and partition in 1947 uprooted the writer from Bombay, forcing him to relocate to Pakistan in 1948. All these experiences informed his stories. Although he is best known for depicting the strife and terror during Indiaâs partition, Mantoâs body of work also includes sharp critiques of social, religious, and political hypocrisy as well as vivid sketches of those living on the fringes of society. His literary styleâclear, concise, and marked by striking endingsâwas shaped by his readings of Western writers such as Guy de Maupassant, O. Henry, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, and W. Somerset Maugham.
Short stories
Some of Mantoâs storiesâsuch as âTamashaâ (1934; âA Spectacleâ), â1919 Ki Ek Baatâ (1951; âIt Happened in 1919â), and âSwaraj Ke Liyeâ (1952; âFor the Sake of Freedomâ)âdrew from the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre, an incident in Amritsar on April 13, 1919, in which British troops opened fire on a large crowd of unarmed Indians, and its aftermath.
Manto was a member of the Progressive Writersâ Association, which included authors such as Mulk Raj Anand, Munshi Premchand, Faiz Ahmed Faiz, and Ismat Chughtai. This movement raised a voice against orthodox writing and regressive society and promoted innovation in Urdu writing. But Manto had disagreements with the members and was expelled from the group.
âToba Tek Singhâ (1955), âThanda Goshtâ (1951; âColder Than Iceâ), and âKhol Doâ (1948; âOpenâ) are among Mantoâs most poignant stories on the partition. Set in a mental institution, âToba Tek Singhâ highlights the madness that ensued after the partition through the tale of an inmate, Bishan Singh. This man refuses to leave Toba Tek Singh, the place he knows as his home, finally dying on the line dividing India and Pakistan. âBordering on the macabre, âThanda Goshtâ explores the psychological aftermath of communal violence: As his mistress stabs him, Ishwar Singh confesses that he had tried to sexually assault a girl, only to realize that she was already dead. âKhol Doâ depicts the harrowing experience of a father searching for his teenage daughter amidst the chaos of partition. It culminates in a tragic moment when, upon hearing the word âopenâ that was intended for a window, the girl begins to mechanically remove her pants.
Among his other popular stories are âBuâ (1940s; âOdorâ), describing the oddities of a sexual encounter, âHatakâ (1941; âInsultâ) on prostitution, and âTitwal Ka Kuttaâ (1951; âThe Dog of Titwalâ) on nationalistic divisions bordering on the cruel and ludicrous. The stories that led to trials on grounds of obscenity and moral perversity are âDhuanâ (1941; âSmokeâ), âKali Shalwarâ (1941; âBlack Trousersâ), âBu,â âThanda Gosht,â âKhol Do,â and âUpar, Neeche, Aur Darmiyanâ (1954; âAbove, Below, and in Betweenâ).
Plays, films, essays, and sketches
Manto penned about 100 radio plays in five collections, written mostly during his time at All India Radio. Like his stories, they are imbued with bitter realism. His collection of plays (1942â45) include Manto ke Dramay (âMantoâs Playsâ), Ao (âComeâ), and Teen Aurten (âThree Womenâ).
The author also worked as a scriptwriter with film studios Bombay Talkies, Filmistan, and Imperial Film Company for films such as Shikari (1946; âHunterâ), Chal Chal Re Naujawan (1944; âKeep Going, Youngstersâ), and Mirza Ghalib (1954). He later turned to writing portraits (essays) of film personalities, including on his friend and actor Ashok Kumar (âAshok Kumar: The Evergreen Heroâ), dancer and film star Sitara Devi (âSitara: The Dancing Tigress from Nepalâ), and actress Nargis (âNargis: Narcissus of the Undying Bloomâ).
Additionally, Manto authored innumerable essays, including âWhy I Write,â as well as short sketches such as âMiracle Manâ and âMistake Removed.â Mantoâs cutting, witty take on a variety of political and socioeconomic issuesâincluding communism, the Cold War, capitalism, and consumerist cultureâis reflected in a set of nine letters addressed to âUncle Samâ (1951â54).
Family, death, and legacy
Translated from Urdu, the epitaph reads: âIn the name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful. Here lies Saadat Hasan Manto buried, and buried with him lie all the secrets of the art of storytelling in his breast. Weighed down by mounds of earth, he wonders still: Who is the greater storyteller, God or he?â The epitaph, written in 1954, months before his death, was not inscribed on his grave for fear of religious retaliation.
Manto married Safia Deen sometime in the mid- to late 1930s and together they had four children, but their firstborn died early. Manto was a devoted father and husband. He faced persistent financial difficulties, especially during his years in Pakistan, where publishers frequently paid him modest sums. His proclivity for alcohol, exacerbated by the trauma of migrating to Pakistan, ultimately led to his death a few months before he turned 43.
Manto is likely the most widely translated Urdu fiction writer; many of his stories are available in several languages. On the 50th anniversary of his death in 2005, the government of Pakistan released a postage stamp featuring his portrait. In 2012 he was posthumously awarded Pakistanâs highest civilian honor, Nishan-e-Imtiaz. Many of Mantoâs works, including âToba Tek Singh,â âKali Shalwar,â and âHatak,â have been adapted for the stage and screen. Two biopics, both titled Mantoâthe first directed by Sarmad Sultan Khoosat in 2015 and the second by Nandita Das in 2018âpay tribute to the writer. But Mantoâs legacy is perhaps best summarized in his own words from Manto on Manto (1951), a sketch he wrote about himself, in which he says: â[I]t may also come to pass that Saadat Hasan may die and Manto may not.â
