Eutyches
-
Who was Eutyches?
Eutyches (c. 375–454) was an archimandrite (monastic superior) in the Eastern Church at Constantinople and the founder of Eutychianism, an extreme form of monophysitism. He believed that Christ's divinity was exclusively prevalent.
Eutyches opposed the Nestorian doctrine, which maintained that Christ had two independent natures. His doctrine was proclaimed heretical in 448, and he was later condemned at the Council of Chalcedon in 451.
Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
What is an abbot in the Orthodox Christian tradition?
An abbot is the leader of a monastic community adhering to the Benedictine Rule, such as Benedictines, Cistercians, Camaldolese, and Trappists, as well as certain other orders.
The term abbot comes from the Aramaic word ab, meaning "father." St. Benedict of Nursia (c. 480–c. 547) revived the term in his rule, combining spiritual fatherhood through teaching with the authority of a father under Roman law. The abbot has complete authority over the monastery’s temporal and spiritual affairs.
In Eastern monasticism, self-governing monasteries are led by several elder monks, whose leader is called abbot.
1 Britannica SourceCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
In what time period did Eutyches live?
Eutyches lived approximately from 375 to 454 CE. He was an archimandrite (a superior abbot in the Eastern Church) in Constantinople and the founder of Eutychianism, a monophysite heresy. Eutyches was initially charged with heresy in 448 by Eusebius of Dorylaeum, then bishop of Dorylaeum, for his monophysite views, which asserted that Jesus Christ had only one nature. The Council of Chalcedon banished Eutyches in 451.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
What was Eutyches's main religious belief?
Eutyches, a 4th–5th-century monk, founded Eutychianism, an extreme form of monophysitism. Monophysitism is the belief that Christ had only one nature, with divinity exclusively prevalent in Christ. In professing one nature in Christ, Eutyches reflected the Eastern monastic view of Christ. His doctrine was considered heretical and was condemned at the Council of Chalcedon.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
Why was Eutyches's belief considered controversial?
Eutyches, a Constantinopolitan abbot, founded Eutychianism, an extreme form of monophysitism that was deemed heretical. Monophysitism emphasizes Christ's divinity over his humanity, suggesting that Christ has one inseparable nature that is at once divine and human rather than having two distinct but unified natures.
Eutyches's belief was controversial because it opposed the doctrine of the Antioch school, which was championed by Nestorius. Nestorius held that Christ had two independent natures, divine as the son of God and human as the son of Mary. Eutyches was deposed and excommunicated for refusing to discuss Christ's natures and declaring that he believed in one nature after the incarnation. The Council of Chalcedon later condemned his heresy and banished him.
3 Britannica SourcesCreated from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles. -
What impact did Eutyches have on the history of Christianity?
Eutyches (c. 375–454) was an archimandrite (monastic superior) in Constantinople and founder of Eutychianism, a form of monophysitism that stressed Christ's divinity.
Eutyches's Christological views, influenced by Cyril of Alexandria, led him to oppose the Antioch school and its Nestorian doctrine, which held that Christ had two distinct natures. Eutyches was summoned to a synod in Constantinople in 448, where his doctrine was denounced as heretical. He maintained that Christ had "two natures before, one after the incarnation," which the synod considered theologically unsophisticated, leading to his deposition and excommunication.
Though Eutyches was later banished and his heresy condemned, his monophysitism influenced the development of national churches in the East.
Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.
Eutyches (born c. 375—died 454) was a revered archimandrite, or monastic superior, in the Eastern Church, at Constantinople, who is regarded as the founder of Eutychianism, an extreme form of the monophysite heresy that emphasizes the exclusive prevalence of the divinity in Christ.
Reared in the Christological doctrine of the Alexandrian school under the influence of Patriarch St. Cyril (died 444), Eutyches, in professing one nature in Christ, reflected the Eastern monastic view of Christ and staunchly opposed the rival Antioch school, which espoused the heterodox doctrine of Nestorius, who was named patriarch in Constantinople in 428. The Nestorian doctrine maintained that Christ had two independent natures: as the son of God, divine; as the son of Mary, human. Thus, it also held that the Virgin was not the mother of God.
Eutyches’ opposition to the Nestorians led Bishop Eusebius of Dorylaeum in Asia Minor to proclaim his doctrine heretical (448). Eutyches then was summoned by Flavian, who had become patriarch of Constantinople and who was an opponent of monophysitism, to a meeting of the standing synod of Constantinople in November 448. There, refusing to discuss Christ’s natures, Eutyches declared that his was the faith of the Fathers at the Council of Nicaea (325), which focused primarily, however, on Christ’s divinity and equality in the Trinity, rather than on Christ’s nature. Eutyches’ repeated affirmation, “two natures before, one after the incarnation,” was his own formula and was a specific expression of the monophysitic doctrine that, in the incarnation, Christ’s human nature was deified and subsumed into a single essence. Hence, he concluded that Christ’s humanity was distinct from that of other men, which some scholars propose was the real formulation of monophysitism. Eutyches’ position was considered to be theologically unsophisticated, and the synod deposed and excommunicated him.
Flavian then reported Eutyches’ heresy to Pope Leo I the Great, who on June 13, 449, issued his celebrated Tome condemning Eutychianism. Eutyches appealed to Patriarch Dioscorus of Alexandria, who supported his Christological doctrines and persuaded the Eastern Roman emperor Theodosius II to summon a general council to meet at Ephesus the following August. The council, later called the Robber Synod and never recognized by Eastern Orthodox and Western churchmen, reinstated Eutyches and deposed Flavian, Eusebius, and other defenders of the two-nature doctrine.
In 450, Emperor Theodosius II was succeeded by Marcian, who convened the Council of Chalcedon in 451; it banished Eutyches, condemned his heresy, and established a centrist doctrine that came to serve as the touchstone of Christian orthodoxy in East and West. The Council held that Christ had two perfect and indivisible, but distinct, natures: one human and one divine. Thereafter, Eutyches disappeared, but his influence nevertheless grew as monophysitism spread throughout the East.
The subsequent history of monophysite doctrine in the Eastern Church is the history of national and independent churches (e.g., the Syrian Jacobites) that, either for reasons of reverence for some religious leader or as a reaction against the dominance of the Byzantine or Roman churches, retained a separate existence.