Britannica Sources used in this answer

What causes the wolf fifth in meantone temperament?

Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.

In meantone temperament, the "wolf" fifth is not caused by a single, isolated error, but rather by the system's inherent limitation in accommodating keys beyond its designed range.12

To achieve pure major thirds, meantone tuning flattens the fifths by a quarter of a comma. Because the keyboard provides only 12 fixed notes per octave, this tuning scheme can only support a limited number of keys (typically those using three sharps and two flats). When a composition requires an enharmonic note outside of this established set—such as needing a D♯ when only an E♭ is available—the resulting interval between the available notes becomes severely out of tune.12

This specific, highly dissonant interval, such as the G♯–E♭ fifth, is nearly two commas out of tune and produces a harsh, beating sound known as the "wolf". This limitation eventually led to the adoption of equal temperament, which distributes tuning imperfections evenly across all keys to allow for greater harmonic flexibility.21