Discover how John Searle's Chinese room argument challenges the Turing test
Learn about John Searle's Chinese room argument, a critique of the Turing test.
© Open University (A Britannica Publishing Partner)
-
© SpaceX/Reuters; music © Ian Post/Artlist.ioSpaceX's Starship V3 megarocket launched on May 22, 2026.
-
Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.Packing cans of fish in Prospect Harbor, Maine.
-
Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.Audrey Tang's goal is to make all information, data, and resources as publicly accessible as possible.
-
© Open University (A Britannica Publishing Partner)An overview of six famous paradoxes in philosophy and science.
-
Public DomainU.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt declares the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, “a date which will live in infamy” during his request to Congress on December 8 that it declare war against Japan.
-
Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.The British Expeditionary Force being surrounded by invading Germans at Dunkirk and evacuated from France by a motley rescue fleet of military ships and private boats; from The Second World War: Triumph of the Axis (1963), a documentary by Encyclopædia Britannica Educational Corporation.
-
Great Museums Television (A Britannica Publishing Partner)An overview of the National WWII Museum (formerly National D-Day Museum) in New Orleans, from the documentary Triumph of the Spirit: The National D-Day Museum.
Transcript
60-Second Adventures in Thought. Number Three, The Chinese Room. Can a machine ever be truly called intelligent? American philosopher and Rhodes Scholar John Searle certainly can. In 1980, he proposed the Chinese room thought experiment in order to challenge the concept of strong artificial intelligence, and not because of some '80s design fad.
He imagines himself in a room with boxes of Chinese characters he can't understand and a book of instructions which he can. If a Chinese speaker outside the room passes him messages under the door, Searle can follow instructions from the book to select an appropriate response. The person on the other side would think they're chatting with a Chinese speaker, just one who doesn't get out much. But really, it's a confused philosopher.
Now according to Alan Turing, the father of computer science, if a computer program can convince a human they're communicating with another human, then it could be said to think. The Chinese room suggests that however well you program a computer, it doesn't understand Chinese. It only simulates that knowledge, which isn't really intelligence. But then, sometimes humans aren't that intelligent, either.
He imagines himself in a room with boxes of Chinese characters he can't understand and a book of instructions which he can. If a Chinese speaker outside the room passes him messages under the door, Searle can follow instructions from the book to select an appropriate response. The person on the other side would think they're chatting with a Chinese speaker, just one who doesn't get out much. But really, it's a confused philosopher.
Now according to Alan Turing, the father of computer science, if a computer program can convince a human they're communicating with another human, then it could be said to think. The Chinese room suggests that however well you program a computer, it doesn't understand Chinese. It only simulates that knowledge, which isn't really intelligence. But then, sometimes humans aren't that intelligent, either.