Why is a manuscript tradition called contaminated when it contains readings from multiple sources?

Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.

In the context of textual criticism, a manuscript tradition is called contaminated (or "open") when a copyist has utilized more than one exemplar or incorporated variants from multiple sources into a single witness.1

This process is referred to as "horizontal" transmission, which contrasts with "vertical" transmission—a "closed" tradition where a copyist follows only one model. In a closed tradition, scholars can use the genealogical or stemmatic method to construct a family tree (stemma codicum) of witnesses to reconstruct the original text. However, when contamination occurs, the relationships between manuscripts become significantly more complex, often making the construction of a clear stemma impossible because multiple textual states coexist within a single document.1

Essentially, contamination represents a blending of different lines of tradition, which complicates the critic's ability to trace the lineage of a text back to its archetype.21