How do de dicto and de re readings of a statement differ?

Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.

The distinction between de dicto and de re readings concerns the scope and focus of modal statements, which describe possibilities, necessities, or contingencies.1

  • De dicto (Latin for "of the word") refers to the modality of propositions. It concerns the relation between a statement and its truth-value. A de dicto reading focuses on whether the proposition itself is necessarily or contingently true, regardless of the specific objects mentioned within it.1
  • De re (Latin for "of the thing") refers to the modality of things. It concerns the relation between objects and their properties. A de re reading focuses on whether a specific object possesses a property essentially (in every possible world where it exists) or accidentally (only in some possible worlds).1

For example, while a de dicto statement might assert that it is necessary that all bachelors are unmarried, a de re perspective would examine whether a specific individual possesses the property of being a bachelor essentially or merely as an accidental feature of their existence.1