Ask the Editor
Question
Is it correct to say "One dog and one cat were lying on the sofa"?
—
Valerie
,
United States
Answer
When two or more nouns are joined by the word "and" it is called a compound subject. Even when each noun is singular, the whole phrase takes a plural verb. Below are some examples of this.
- Her book and her purse are sitting on the table.
- An apple and an orange were left in the cafeteria.
- Cheryl and Frank are traveling to Japan next month.
When a compound subject is joined by the word "or" an English teacher will tell you that the verb should agree with the noun closest to it. When each noun in a compound subject with "or" is singular, the verb should be singular too. These rules are followed in formal writing, but the choice between a singular and plural verb often varies in actual use. Below are some examples of this.
- Either John or his sisters are calling us tonight.
- The house key or the car key is missing from his key ring.
- Either those books or that box are good enough to use as a table for now.
- One or more of us is going to have to move over to make room.
- He knows a banana or an orange is waiting for him in his lunchbox.
- The girls or their mother have to come with us to pick out a gift.
I hope this helps. For more posts about words and usage, like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter!
You can read more articles in the
archive.