Britannica Sources used in this answer

What did Bernard Williams mean by ā€œinternal reasonsā€ for action?

Created from Britannica articles using AI. AI can make mistakes, so verify using Britannica articles.

In the philosophy of Bernard Williams, the concept of "internal reasons" for action is central to his critique of moral theories that rely on impersonal, universal standards.

Williams argued that for a reason to be a genuine reason for an agent to act, it must be "internal"—meaning it must be connected to the agent's existing "subjective motivational set." This set includes a person’s desires, projects, commitments, and other motives that they already possess. According to Williams, reasons for action cannot be created by the force of reason alone or by external moral requirements that are disconnected from an individual's actual motivations.

By insisting that practical reasons must be internal, Williams challenged the idea that one could derive objective, universal moral obligations that apply to everyone regardless of their personal point of view. He believed that the ambition to transcend one's own perspective in the practical domain is fundamentally misguided, as it ignores the personal projects and relations that give human life its meaning.1